Chris Israel on 3 strikes scam
p2pnet news view P2P | Politics:- Jim Gianopulos, the man who runs Fux Filmed Entertainment, wants America to pass a law similar to France`s `three strikes` rule that would allow a judge to order Internet service providers to disconnect users who download copyrighted material, p2pnet said on Tuesday.
His comments came “as Sens. Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Sherrod Brown of Ohio wrote to the Obama administration, expressing their concern over the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement, which the world’s top nations are negotiating, largely in secret talks,” says Sam Gustin (right) in DailyFinance, pointing out ACTA is a global trade agreement focusing on intellectual property.
“Some among its potential signatories want to make it easier to crack down on digital piracy, but critics charge that they want to cut off alleged offenders’ Web connections, as well as make it easier for authorities to search and even seize personal computers at the airport in an effort to root out copyright infringement,” he says, continuing »»»
Chris Israel, the Bush administration’s coordinator for international intellectual property enforcement, thinks such concerns are wildly overblown. “A lot of the ’seize your iPod at the border’ stuff is manufactured out of thin air to fan the flames,” he says. Israel is managing partner at PCT Government Relations, which represents a major media company involved in the talks that Israel declines to name. Also under discussion: a measure that would provide a “safe harbor” for ISPs, protecting them for prosecution if they comply with the tough measures to identify and sanction alleged internet pirates.
Unfortunately, the treaty’s secrecy has made it difficult to learn its status. Proponents of harsher copyright enforcement call the treaty’s critics “alarmist,” but the treaty’s lack of transparency has created a fog of confusion. To remedy the situation, U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (a Vermont indepdenent) and Sherrod Brown (an Ohio Democrat) sent a letter to U.S. Trade Representative Ron Kirk, ojecting to the government’s secrecy and asking “that the public be allowed to review and comment on substantive proposals for a new Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement.”
“The public has a right to monitor and express informed views on proposals of such magnitude,” the senators argued. “For that to happen, they need to have access to information, including relevant meeting details such as time, place, agenda and participants, reports or minutes of meetings, and key documents and negotiating texts distributed to all members of the negotiation.” The two senators point out that Obama’s January 21, 2009 “Memorandum on Transparency and Open Government” emphasizes “the importance of transparency, public participation, and collaboration in government.”
“We are concerned that the secrecy of such information reflects a desire to avoid potential criticism of substantive provisions in the ACTA by the public, the group who will be most affected by the agreement,” the senators said.
But Israel says concerns over transparency are unfounded. “The process behind ACTA is not substantively different from similar trade agreements,” he says. “This is an agreement between leading economies on intellectual property that seeks to tie together various individual bilateral agreements in a more comprehensive way. It’s just a good thing to do.”
“I think it’s more transparent to have a standard, rather than a bunch of individual agreements,” he says. “But it’s not something you can negotiate online in the blogopshere. This involves senior officials talking in confidence with each other, going over the text line by line.”
The senators’ letter comes as powerful Hollywood sources increase their calls for a crackdown on internet piracy, which they say costs the film and music industries billions in revenue every year. This month, Rupert Murdoch expressed support for a three-strikes-like plan. “There’s a lot of movement to get that put in America and become a world standard,” Murdoch told Sky News, “because in the music industry today, it’s very, very hard for young talent to get started and established.”
Libertarian activists and consumer groups “have blasted ACTA on both its secrecy and its harsh penalies.” observes Gustin adding:
“Many consumer groups feel that powerful corporate interests are disproportionally shaping the outcome — with little or no public involvement. ‘The public has a right to know the contents of the proposals being considered under ACTA, just as they have a right to read the text of bills pending before Congress,’ Sanders and Brown said.”
p2pnet isn`t a business. It`s a commitment. If it has value for you, please think about making a contribution to help me keep it online. Cheers! And thanks : )
(If you`d like to help but don`t fancy online payments, please email me at p2pnet @ shaw dot ca and I`ll send you my snail-mail address.)
First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win ~ Mahatma Gandhi
p2pnet – `We Want Three Strikes!` Fox, November 24, 2009
expressing their concern – ACTA spells EVIL, November 25, 2009
DailyFinance – Senators blast Obama’s secret trade talks as Fox head calls for ‘3 strikes’, November 25, 2009
Use free p2pnet newsfeeds for your site. It`s really easy!
Subscribe to p2pnet.net | | rss feed: http://p2pnet.net/p2p.rss | | Mobile – http://p2pnet.net/index-wml.php
Net access blocked by government restrictions? Use Psiphon from the Citizen Lab at the University of Toronto. Go here for details.
November 27th, 2009 at 7:11 am
When its clear politicians are not acting for the good of the people they do not deserve office nor respect, deny them both and make as much noise and fuss about it as you can to remind other petty despots just what their job entails.
November 28th, 2009 at 8:43 am
âThe process behind ACTA is not substantively different from similar trade agreements,â he says. âThis is an agreement between leading economies on intellectual property that seeks to tie together various individual bilateral agreements in a more comprehensive way. Itâs just a good thing to do.â Chris Israel
YEEAA Im sure its a “good thing” (MarthaStewart TM) to keep members of the public in the dark while negotiations are made on the international stage without their knowledge. Did I get that right Mr Israel?
Please someone inform Mr Israel that negotiations have never been like this before.
Population of countries negotiating ACTA: 1,178,504,491
Members of the public with access to ACTA text: 42