Ed Felten’s 2005 predictions
p2p news / p2pnet: Last January, professor Ed Felten made a number of predictions for 2005.
How’d he do? It’s time to find out >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
2005 Predictions Scorecard
By Ed Felten – Freedom to Tinker
(1) DRM technology, especially on PCs, will be seen increasingly as a security and privacy risk to end users.
The SonyBMG fiasco fulfilled this prediction.
Verdict: Right.
(2) Vonage and other leading VoIP vendors will start to act like incumbents, welcoming regulation of their industry sector.
We did see Vonage embrace 911 regulation (only to back away from it later). But that’s about all.
Verdict: Mostly wrong.
(3) Internet Explorer will face increasing competitive pressure from Mozilla Firefox. Microsoft’s response will be hamstrung by its desire to maintain the fiction that IE is an integral part of the operating system.
Firefox did make headway, and Microsoft was held back initially by a desire to hold back IE updates until the next version of Windows was issued.
Verdict: Mostly right.
(4) As blogs continue to grow in prominence, we’ll see consolidation in the blog world, with major bloggers either teaming up with each other or affiliating with major news outlets or web sites.
We did see plenty of consolidation: TPM Cafe, Pajamas Media, Huffington Post, and so on.
Verdict: Right.
(5) A TV show or movie that is distributed only on the net will become a cult hit.
Readers informed me that this one was already true (Red vs. Blue). Perhaps I wasn’t predicting that this would happen, but that I would learn about it.
No verdict.
(6) The Supreme Court’s Grokster decision won’t provide us with a broad, clear rule for evaluating future innovations, so the ball will be back in Congress’s court.
The Court didn’t give us a bright-line rule, but Congress has kept its hands off, presumably on the theory that the Court’s decision is the best result that is feasible.
Verdict: Mostly right.
(7) Copyright issues will be stalemated in Congress.
Many bills were introduced, but no major bills came close to passing.
Verdict: Right.
(8) There will be no real progress on the spam, spyware, and desktop security problems.
Verdict: Right.
(9) Congress will address the spyware problem by passing a harmless but ineffectual law, which critics will deride as the “CAN-SPY Act.”
No such bill was passed.
Verdict: Wrong.
(10) DRM technology will still fail to prevent widespread infringement. In a related development, pigs will still fail to fly.
I predict this every year, and it’s always right. This prediction is so obvious that it’s almost unfair to count it.
Verdict: Right.
(11) New P2P systems will marry swarming distribution (as in BitTorrent) with distributed indexing (as in Kazaa et al). Copyright owners will resort to active technical measures to try to corrupt the systems’ indices.
There was talk about such systems, but no good ones were developed, so copyright owners didn’t have to respond to them.
Verdict: Mostly wrong.
(12) X-ray vision technology will become more widely available (though not to the general public), spurring a privacy hoohah.
There was some discussion about airport security machines that can see through clothes, but they weren’t widely deployed and the privacy discussion was fairly minor.
Verdict: Mostly wrong.
The final score: five right, two mostly right, three mostly wrong, one wrong. Obviously my predictions weren’t sufficiently outrageous. Next: predictions for 2006.
